Should you lot pay a apartment monthly accuse for electricity?
An offering comes inwards the postal service today from Georgia Power , a Southern Company whose stock I sold a few weeks ago. Southern Company has gotten into or thus hot H2O lately , trying to construct 2 nuclear ability plants hither inwards Georgia in addition to a "clean coal" constitute inwards Mississippi. While at the fourth dimension these were planned , they seemed similar forward-looking high-tech solutions to the unloose energy work , but since thus , cheap natural gas has flooded the marketplace position , making both plants unprofitable. Cost overruns sealed the grapple in addition to bankrupted Westinghouse in addition to threaten to destroy Toshiba.
The missive inwards the postal service today offers an interesting grapple - their Flatbill program allows me to pay $180.32 a calendar month for electricity for 12 months , no affair how much I use , fifty-fifty though this is $8.56 more per calendar month than my average usage. This is non their erstwhile Budget Bill where you lot paid a apartment charge per unit of measurement based on average consumption , in addition to thus at the halt of the twelvemonth , were issued a credit (or paid the deficit) on the actual amount used. This actually is a flat-rate plan. You utilisation equally much juice equally you lot desire , in addition to pay a apartment fee.
What's the catch? Why would they offering this?
Well the bit response is easier to figure out. For residential customers , the amount collected inwards fees is to a greater extent than of a pain-in-the-ass for most utility companies. Metering ability in addition to sending out meter readers is expensive. Their big customers (business in addition to industry) pay most of the toll of running the utility company. Individual consumers are but , good , a nuisance. So if you lot could larn people to piece of work out to a flat-rate excogitation , such equally Budget Bill or Flatbill , you lot don't get got to read the meter - non fifty-fifty electronically - for 12 months.
In a agency , it is similar the "too inexpensive to meter" promises of nuclear ability inwards the 1950's. Just accuse a apartment fee for "all you lot tin ship away eat" in addition to go done amongst it. There are billing savings for the utility.
So what's the catch? Why non sign upward in addition to thus leave all the lights on , in addition to plough the A/C downward to lx in addition to the oestrus upward to 80? What is the incentive to conserve energy?
Well , it is even thus there. Your next year's flatbill volition go based on final year's consumption. So if you lot waste matter unloose energy , your neb side past times side twelvemonth volition reverberate that. There Ain't No Such Thing As Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 Free Lunch! So they pick out handle of upward amongst you lot , eventually. You sign upward for i twelvemonth , in addition to the side past times side twelvemonth , your Flatbill volition piece of work out a Fatbill - it volition skyrocket if you lot swallow to a greater extent than unloose energy than you lot commonly do.
In add-on , you lot are paying , inwards my instance , $8.56 to a greater extent than a calendar month for juice , to embrace "overages , etc." or close $102.72 inwards excess charges. In other words , nearly a month's unloose energy neb extra.
It is an interesting concept , but it doesn't make the stingy test. With the electrical flow billing arrangement , where I pay past times the kilowatt-hour , I get got or thus command over my destiny. If I plough off a low-cal , I pay less. If I switch to LED bulbs , I pay less. If I plough the A/C thermostat upward to 78 (where it is today) I pay less. If I seat inwards energy-saver windows , I pay less. If I leave of absence the forepart door opened upward in addition to the A/C on , I pay a heckofa lot more.
The Flatbill excogitation disconnects usage from savings. If I produce whatsoever of these energy-saving things , I produce non run across whatsoever immediate consequence , until they Flatbill resets for side past times side year. Only thus mightiness my neb piece of work out down. If I indulge myself , knowing the neb won't piece of work out upward correct away , when the Flatbill resets for side past times side twelvemonth , it mayhap good over $200 a calendar month (with a higher "add-on" fee equally well).
If my unloose energy consumption stays the same , I pay an additional $102.72 a twelvemonth for "convenience" - in addition to nosotros all know what Sooze Orman says close "convenience" now!
If my unloose energy consumption stays the same , I pay an additional $102.72 a twelvemonth for "convenience" - in addition to nosotros all know what Sooze Orman says close "convenience" now!
The temptation is - in addition to it is temptation - to sign upward for this in addition to country , "Yahoo! I tin ship away directly utilisation electricity similar it's free!" And for a few months you lot may larn away amongst that. And mayhap you lot could sign upward for a twelvemonth in addition to alive this agency in addition to thus piece of work out dorsum to regular metered billing. Perhaps. But you'd amend fourth dimension this exactly , equally it appears to go a negative-option contract. You sign upward for 12 months , in addition to you lot thus get got to cancel after the 12 calendar month period but earlier the Flatbill automatically renews (according to the damage of the alphabetic lineament sent to me). If you lot take away from the excogitation inside a 12 calendar month flow , you lot get got to pay the excess electricity you lot used higher upward that billed nether the Flatbill plan. So if you lot piece of work out agency over $180.32 a calendar month (in my example) in addition to cancel xi months in addition to 29 days after , you lot get got to pay for all that excess usage. Wait equally good long to cancel renewal , in addition to you lot are automatically renewed inwards a novel plan - in addition to the same cancellation damage apply.
And they ain't giving away the shop - if your usage is 50% or to a greater extent than than the previous year's usage for the same month , you lot may go kicked dorsum to the residential metering excogitation , just equally if you lot cancelled earlier the 12-month contract was up , in addition to forced to pay the difference. This final purpose is troubling to me , equally nosotros go inwards the summertime months , in addition to our monthly bills tin ship away vary wildly. For illustration , final month's neb was over $300 amongst the early on summertime heat. Last August's neb was $78 equally nosotros were away in addition to left the thermostat ready at 85 degrees. If nosotros were hither inwards August , our electricity neb would easily piece of work past times 50% to a greater extent than than $78 in addition to kicking us out of the plan.
The to a greater extent than complicated you lot tin ship away brand whatsoever fiscal transaction , the easier it is to fleece the consumer. And inwards this instance , you lot are signing a contract - i amongst a whole dorsum page of fine impress damage that spell out bad things that will hap to you if you lot don't follow the rules , but non a lot of bad things that hap to Georgia Power. You pay to a greater extent than , but you lot larn the same , basically. The are selling "Peace of Mind" in addition to you lot know how I experience close that. The plebes latch onto this form of crap , equally they are living paycheck-to-paycheck in addition to the high electrical bills of summertime always come upward equally a surprise to them. Plus , they are fervent believers inwards free ponies.
So the sentiment that you lot are getting "free electricity" or that you lot no longer ask to conserve unloose energy is flawed. If you lot actually waste matter ability , they toss you lot out of the plan. If you lot utilisation a lot of juice , your side past times side year's Flatbill rates volition piece of work out up. At best you lot may go able to "scam" Georgia Power for a twelvemonth , but the side past times side twelvemonth , you'd get got to drib out of the excogitation , otherwise go zinged amongst a high flat-rate plan. And when you lot drib out , go real careful of the dropout dates in addition to deadlines equally it is a negative pick plan. I don't hear existence negative option amongst Georgia Power , but on a month-to-month the world , please!
This offering does illustrate how residential customers are to a greater extent than of a nuisance than anything to a utility , in addition to how much unloose energy nosotros consumer is secondary to the real fact nosotros are connected to the grid in addition to get got to go billed (and they get got to collect). It also illustrates how our natural gas glut has made ability a lot cheaper - in addition to if it weren't for these ill-fated ability constitute projects , we'd go paying a lot less for electricity!
Paying nearly $10 to a greater extent than a calendar month on my electrical neb for "convenience" doesn't seem similar a big "savings" to me. I intend I'll get got a pass.
UPDATE: Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 reader notes that just the agency the grapple is presented - amongst a flashy brochure in addition to lots of fine impress on the dorsum of the "letter" tips the whole thing off. You tin ship away location a bad grapple at 100 paces , over fourth dimension , but from the agency it is pitched to you.
UPDATE: Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 reader notes that just the agency the grapple is presented - amongst a flashy brochure in addition to lots of fine impress on the dorsum of the "letter" tips the whole thing off. You tin ship away location a bad grapple at 100 paces , over fourth dimension , but from the agency it is pitched to you.
EmoticonEmoticon